» Subscribe to Newsletter
» Switch to BizTech2.com
                       
Home » Features » Home Theater Systems HiFi & TV » Home Theater Myths: Part Two
Home Theater Myths: Part Two
By: Siddharth Bhatia   |   Jan 24, 2009

This is a continuation of the Home theater myths article done 2 weeks ago, where we covered some basic facts - upscaling, speaker cables, cable TV resolution - about Home Theater systems. Here are a few more. These aren't as straight up as the previous myths but are relevant enough for consumers looking to set up their first home theaters.

Myth: Manufacturer specs are to be believed
Definitely not. Especially LCD TVs and the like, where the number of sales matters more than the number of satisfied customers. Now I'm not saying that stalwarts like Sony, Samsung, Panasonic are out there scamming us - everyone is playing a game, a highly competitive one at that. Thus sometimes you will hear stuff like 100,000:1 dynamic contrast, response time of 6 ms, or 2 ms or whatever. The thing is we do not know how and where they are measured, and the main problem is that these are not for the public to see or know. The process is not yet standardized thus manufacturers get away with whatever they want. The definition of dynamic contrast itself allows the manufacturer a certain level of ambiguity in measurement. Normal Contrast Ratio is a measurement of the difference between the blackest black and the whitest white that the display can actually display. Dynamic Contrast is when the back lighting is adjusted dynamically for darker scenes to give you better black levels. Who knows what and how they adjust? Technically speaking, in our regular LCDs (not LED backlit ones), fluorescent backlighting is used, and one complete 'slab' lights the whole pixel matrix, thus it is impossible to have such high ratios of light to dark, as light will bleed through the individual pixels. Read reviews and do a bit of A/B comparison yourself in the stores.

Myth: Plasmas and LCDs have a short life
They actually do not. Let me wrap up LCDs first. The lamp used to backlight the display is a sturdy fluorescent lamp, a tried and tested sturdy technology that can last quite long. The circuitry and LCD screen itself should not be toyed around with and there will be no need to buy a new TV every 18 months. Of course you can replace your LCD for a newer technology like LED technology, but those are so expensive in India that we might as well wait. Plasmas too have been touted as delicate due to something called 'burn in'. But new models of Plasma TVs too can last long, and burn in should not be a problem as long as the contrast is not set too high. Maximum healthy contrast should be at 85%. Even then if the CNBC or CNN logo seems stuck to your plasma after repeated watching, you can use a simple full white screen and keep playing it for a day or two. These will affect the phosphors and possibly burn them back to normal. A full white screen is available on calibration DVDs like DVE or Displaymate software.


Ads by Google 
Post a Comment on “Home Theater Myths: Part Two”
Comment : 
Name : 
City : 
Email : 
DR ABHAY MAHANKAL
You are a moron. I wonder where you got the Dr tag added from. The article only simplifies things for people taking out the unnecessary and allowing them to not get carried away by unnecessary specs. For example the comment on the speaker cables if you have ever in your life been to a high end audio store you will realize the number of cables available. The reason they are there is because a person buying a 1,50,000 and above speaker system will not think twice before spending another 20K on wires + another 10 K on connectors. The article tells you not to get fooled by them marketing. How does that confuse you. But i guess sometimes Dr (if you really are on or just wanted it to add credibility ) do then to over complicate simple things or you are just a moron.
Rohit @ Oct 01, 2009
good article, but can the writer guide me on one problem i am facing? i have a Harman Kardon AVR 155 with 5.1 speakers & i am experiencing that volume of dialogues is noticibly lower than the songs or background music.. is it normal or how can it be rectified?
Karan Jain @ Jun 27, 2009
is there any possibility of receiving 5.1 audio via satellite channels in the near future. Is there any such transmission in India and is there any receiver to process 5.1?
Answer this and you wud get 2 paise as reward.
softom @ Feb 13, 2009
Be cautious while writing anything, YOU ARE WATCHED AND FOLLOWED
DR ABHAY MAHANKAL @ Feb 07, 2009
Excellent, this is awesome thank you so much.

But which one do you think is the best LCD or the PLASMA w.r.t technology, durability
Kalyan @ Feb 05, 2009
Can you explain a bit about Optical outs? My DVD player has a Component video but only stereo out. But both the player and my amp support optical cables. Does optical cable transmit a raw signal, so to speak - 5.1 ?
Sudarshan @ Feb 02, 2009
i think that doctor is a troll, screw off abhay mahankal...there is nothing wrong with the article
tech2fan @ Jan 28, 2009
nice criticisms. But why the writer so personalize to say " we did not come to your place? it seems such a remark has disturbed the writer. But criticism must be answered in proper way than individualizing it. Please stop arguing. both of you tkae it in good spirit,
VINOD SHAH @ Jan 28, 2009
I did not get confused. I liked the article, it was quite nice
shekhar @ Jan 27, 2009
@ Dr Abhay Mahankal

HI Abhay Mahankal

We at tech2.com, CNBC or entire Network 18 never tried to fool anyone, and never will. I have done half a dozen basic articles a year back on fundamentals of home theater, jargon busters, AV recievers etc. please browse a bit before posting. Still, there are more coming, and we will redo most of them as per schedule.

Further trolling will be simply deleted
Siddharth Bhatia @ Jan 27, 2009
@ Ketan

Hi Ketan

Dolby has better compression ratios mainly, the data rate is 448 kbps on a DVD. Thus people say DTS is better as there is lesser lossy compression, the DTS data rate is higher, at 754 kbps.

Even the way it is recorded on a film strip is different. Dolby goes directly on the 35mm film strip, while Dolby is stored separate, with just a time code on the film strip. more on this in an article we will do.
Siddharth Bhatia @ Jan 27, 2009
@ swapnil

Hi Swapnil.
There are many great DVDs
I am Legend, StarWars box set( every Home theater owner must have this title) Lord of the Rings. another personal fav is King Kong, and i just got my hands on Wall E DVD Its very nice.

DVDs cost that much only, there is no other legal way of enjoying movies.

AVMAX is a great magazine for overall Indian Audio Video industry.
Siddharth Bhatia @ Jan 27, 2009
Like i mentioned in many other reviews the same query but no one replied it please help me out:

I wanna know 2 things:

1) Which are the best Dolby Digital movie DVDs which can give the maximum effect u have came across. (or u use them to test any home theater).
2) Dvds come a bit expensive i.e. from 500/- bucks and on, can u suggest some better way to enjoy DVDs at less cost.
3) Are there some magzines which give away Demo disks for Home Theater Experince (or any place from where we can buy them) .

Plz reply Siddhart man!!!!!!!!
Swapnil @ Jan 27, 2009
Dear Siddhata

I think you have not noted the cooments I posted on your first article. Please do not fool readers,

Dear Readers
He has confused you more than educating, SOUND AND PROJECTION OF LIGHT ARE NOT SO EASY TO UNDERSTAND. LOTS DEPENDS ON YOUR KNOWLEDGE AND BUDGET, INSTEAD OF TELLING HOW TO HAVE A SYSTEM OF YOUR CHOICE HE HAS MORE CONFUSED YOU.THERE ARE MANY WEB SITE TO TELL YOU ABOUT THIS WHOLE CONCEPT, JUST BROWSE THE WEB AND YOU WILLL REALIZE HOW FOOLED YOU ARE BY THIS ARTICLE.
DR ABHAY MAHANKAL @ Jan 27, 2009
Nice article..
snakey @ Jan 26, 2009
WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN DOLBY DIGITAL AND DTS
I KNOW THEY ARE TWO DIFFERENT CO. HAVING DIFF. SOUND FORMAT BUT WHAT'S THE TECHNICAL DIFFERENCE
KETAN @ Jan 26, 2009
superb stuff.
part one was a bit generic, but this on is great. Please elaborate more on manufacturer specs
shekhar @ Jan 26, 2009
what the hell is in Page 3?

Ghost page!!!! Boooooo
Vineeth Jose @ Jan 25, 2009
page 3's blank!!!
dude @ Jan 25, 2009
I liked both part 1 and 2.
Please also include various connectivity options in TV and speakers too.
Like for video 'component / composite / HDMI / VGA - DVI (PC out)' and more
And audio - RCA / sterio(3.5mm jack) / digital / SPDIF out / optical and so on.

People must know the image quality difference betn them. In india these connectivities wont make difference as TV signal itself is low quality , but when u have HTPC it surely will help.
For audio myths , people buy decent DVD players in range of 4-5k those support Upsacling. but most of them dont have analog 5.1 audio output. only digital / SPDIF. so cheap 5.1 analog systems cannt take advantg of surround sound.

And in virtual surround techs ,i liked many , mentioned
SRS sandbox
SRS circle surround provide good virtual sound on PC.
adisal @ Jan 24, 2009
Ads by Google 
Ads by Google
Products
Camcorders  |   Controllers  |   CPUs  |   Desktop PCs  |   Digital Cameras  |   Digital Video Recorders  |   DVD Players  |   Games  |   Gaming Consoles  |   General  |   GPS Systems  |   Handhelds / PDAs  |   Hard Drives  |   Headphones & Headsets  |   HiFi Audio Systems  |   Home Theater Systems  |   Input Devices  |   Internet  |   Laptops  |   lenovo  |   Low Level Components  |   Mac Systems  |   Mobile Phone Accessories  |   Mobile Phones  |   Monitors  |   Motherboards  |   MP3 / Audio Players  |   Multi-Function Devices  |   Networking  |   Optical Drives  |   PC Add-on Cards  |   PC Cabinets  |   PC Games  |   Printers  |   Projectors  |   RAM Modules  |   Scanners  |   Software  |   Speakers  |   Telecom  |   TVs  |   Video Players  |  
Careers | About Us | Tech2 Staff | Ad Inventory | Site Profile | Copyright © 2007, Tech2.com India - A Network 18 India Venture