REVIEWS / SPEAKERS / JBL INDIA

Value For MoneyJBL SCS 200.5 Review

20 Dec, 2012, 12:44 pm IST | by Karan Gour | Speakers

Speakers

An entry-level 5.1 speaker system that's great value for money

An entry-level 5.1 speaker system that's great value for money
Dimensions of the sub-woofer and satellites
The rear of the centre piece
Connections behind the amp

PRICE IN INDIA

25,000

TECH2 RATING

8.0

AVERAGE USER RATING

7.0

How we test

CONTACT

JBL INDIA

 savio.fernandes@indiajbl.com

 +91 22 3008 0840/50

 www.indiajbl.com

There are plenty of 5.1 speaker packages in the market that cater to every single budget bracket out there. Since we are concerning ourselves with the entry-level bracket this month, it’s fair to say that out of these scores of options, only a few can qualify to be reviewed this time. The JBL SCS 200.5 speaker setup seemed full of potential, especially when you take a look at its stands.

An entry-level 5.1 speaker system that's great value for money

An entry-level 5.1 speaker system that's great value for money

 

 

Out of the box

This speaker setup comprises satellites and a subwoofer, all of which are bathed in the matte black finish that can never go wrong. The risk, however, was taken in the cabinet design of these satellites because they are more triangular than curvy. We’ve seen several speakers in the past that have adopted the curved cabinet, which is usually a curve that goes from left to right, but this might be the first time we’ve encountered satellites that curve from top to bottom. This gives each of these little speakers more bulk, although they do have a tough time standing without their stands. Speaking of which, these stands are made of almost-bendable plastic and are shaped to form an ‘I’ as their footprint. They slide into a slot in the back panel, so they hide the spring speaker terminals. The wire can be made to go through the hollow plastic stand so that it doesn’t look ugly. Two screws are used to keep the stand in place. The subwoofer is simple with its tallish appearance and the standard JBL logo set upon the grey bass port on the front. I like the way things are turning out because the potential is getting that much bigger.

Dimensions of the sub-woofer and satellites

Dimensions of the sub-woofer and satellites

 

 

Technology

Each of the satellites, excluding the centre, comes with two drivers—a 0.5-inch titanium-laminate dome tweeter and a 3” mid-range woofer. The centre just has an added mid-range woofer that’s used, along with the other, to sandwich the tweeter in the centre of the front baffle. The fact that these satellites can go as low as 110Hz seems not the least bit of a stretch because it’s quite attainable even when the speakers are of such a diminutive size. With the help of the titanium-laminate material, JBL claims that the accuracy of the high frequency response remains accurate even when the level is way up. Since the entire front baffle seems to be on a curve, the dispersion must be on the higher side and it should be because of them being satellite speakers.

The rear of the centre piece

The rear of the centre piece

 

 

The subwoofer is built with a 100W RMS amplifier and can go as low as 35 Hz and as high as 160 Hz. There’s an 8-inch woofer that’s bottom firing and the 3-inch feet help to keep it a good distance above the ground. As for the back panel, you have the option of connecting three different input methods—LFE or Low Frequency Effects, L and R. You should opt for LFE if you’re going to be using it as the .1 channel in a 5.1 environment. There are also four pairs of speaker level terminals along with a simple level knob on the top of the back panel and the power switch on the bottom. That’s what you call a basic subwoofer with just the bare essentials as far as tweaking goes.

 

Performance

The only thing that took a while to set up were the fronts because of the stands that needed to be screwed in place. Thankfully, all the cables were already changed to strip so there was no need for recabling. For the surrounds and the centre, I could’ve used the stands, but their placement was such that I could just lean them sturdily enough on one side or the other.

 

I was ready to go on my adventure with the 3D Blu-ray of ‘Journey 2: The Mysterious Island’ that boasts of some of the greatest home-entertainment 3D I’ve seen in recent times. But the part I love most is the way the sound matches the depth of the visuals and I was fortunate to have the SCS 200.5 by my side. They take a little while to get your mind off the fact that you’re listening to satellite speakers because they honestly do sound like they are coming from small cabinets. The subwoofer does help them get some added size, but since even that can’t go as low as 20Hz, you do feel like you’re missing some of that meat during the action sequences. However, after about ten minutes, you’ve forgotten about the speakers and their sizes. All you hear is a spot-on soundstage that’s beamed across the entire room, with you at the centre of it. The subwoofer is powerful for our little room and I had it down to its lowest position so that it didn’t overpower the rest of the satellites.

Connections behind the amp

Connections behind the amp

 

 

The satellites in-turn were mesmerising. They had such a firm grip on the mid-range that both the sound effects and the music kept our eyes off the bad acting on screen. I found myself forgiving so much of the film because of its extremely well-done soundtrack. Take for instance, the scene where the helicopter is being swallowed by the tornado at sea. The swirling of the powerful wind sends the surrounds and us spinning as quickly as the helicopter is getting sucked in. I can hear all sorts of particles hitting the glass of the helicopter and when one of the windows breaks, the satellites rise above this level and deliver the sonic impact.

 

All this while, I could hear the dialogues of the characters like I was in a movie theatre. They seemed to have so much of meat in them that I kind of hoped that even the satellites had that extra mid-range driver like the centre did. Our DVD of ‘Kickass’ was just as entertaining and thrilling with scenes like the burning of Nicholas Cage and Aaron Johnson getting beaten up when he tries to defend a man from hoodlums in the middle of the street. Every kick, punch and moan is perfectly articulated and I could tell that these satellites had effortlessly disappeared into the darkness.

 

I think my only problem with these speakers is their dropping treble range. It felt like I was listening to a worn out set of speakers as the highs sounded blunted, especially with sound effects like gunshots and when the string section of a background score rises above the rest of the instruments. What is fascinating is that in this price range, 90 percent of the speaker packages will have the opposite with a peaking high-frequency response. I guess this complaint then would just be me expecting far too much from this Rs 25,000 speaker setup.

 

Verdict and price in India

JBL’s SCS 200.5 speaker package is a very tough competitor for all of its competitors. It has experimental yet acceptable aesthetics and a sonic performance that will knock the socks off your feet. Its blunted highs was really the only thing I wished could’ve been corrected and that really says a lot about a 25 grand 5.1 speaker package. Be it action, drama or just plain old silence with a background score, the 200.5 speaker package delivers with might, power and accuracy. I implore you, get them even if you don’t need them!

 

 

 

 

AV MAX is a special interest audiophile magazine that focuses on reviewing  high-end AV equipment like amplifiers, stereos, floorstanding speakers and related news

AV MAX is a special interest audiophile magazine that focuses on reviewing high-end AV equipment like amplifiers, stereos, floorstanding speakers and related news


Tags:

JBL SCS 200.5 , JBL SCS 200.5 review , JBL SCS 200.5 features , JBL SCS 200.5 specifications , JBL SCS 200.5 specs , JBL SCS 200.5 price in India , JBL SCS 200.5 Indian pricing , JBL , JBL india , budget 5.1 speakers , budget home theater speakers , entry-level 5.1 speakers , entry-level home theater speakers , affordable 5.1 speakers , affordable home theater speakers , 5.1 speakers under rs , JBL 5.1 speakers

Would you buy it?




 


How We Test

The Tech2 Labs receives many products every single week and each of them is tested with the utmost care and highest level of objectivity. There’s a constant effort to reduce and totally eliminate subjectivity. Each product is tested according to set test processes so the same test scenario is used.

Verdict
The ratings awarded to a product are derived from a number of tests and calculations, keeping certain important factors in mind. These factors consist of features, performance, quality and value for money. In case of software and some other categories, build quality might be replaced with ease of use or ease of installation. Products are compared with other products in a similar price range or product category.


Features
The features component of the score is rated based on the kind of features present on a particular product. Features are a big part of what people look for when they’re buying a new product such as a phone or a camera.

Performance
The performance score is derived from the benchmarks and tests run on the product. In case of the subjective scores, an average of the scores given by the group of reviewers is considered.

Build Quality
The build quality of a product is important so that it doesn’t fall apart after some use. The build quality scores from the way the product is designed and the kind of materials used in the product.

Value
Value for money comes from the fact that a cheap product is able to provide most of the performance of a higher priced product. Once again, value for money is judged by comparing pricing and performance of products in a particular price range or category. 

There are many other aspects of the product that are looked at such as the bundled software and accessories. All of these scores are aggregated together to form the final score.

What do the ratings mean?

Ratings are simple - higher the score, the better the product. A brief listing of the features and what they mean are given below.

1 - 3

The product is bad in almost every aspect. We strongly advise against purchasing this product.

4 - 6

An average product that isn't the best you can buy, but isn't the worst either.

7 - 8

Product with this rating is highly recommended because it's priced sensibly, has a good set of features and performs well.

9 - 10

Exceptionally excellent product with features and performance unlike any we've seen in the past. A must-have for everyone!

What is the Average User Rating?

We at Tech2 take product reviewing very seriously and every product is tested with the utmost care and level of objectivity. The end user who buys a particular product and uses it over an extended period of time has his own take on a product and there might be nuances that he or she can shed light on. The Average User Rating is present to help readers get the complete picture of how good or bad a product is. The Average User Rating is calculated by averaging the ratings by the thousands of readers visiting Tech2.com every single day. To record your own rating of a product, simply click on the user rating bar. If you disagree with our ratings or our community's product rating, please don't hesitate from voicing your opinion in the comments section below the review.

Leaked Images, Availability, Pricing,
Specs, Pre-order

Asus Transformer AiO Review

Asus Transformer AiO Review

18 Jun, 2013, 02:20 AM

Alcatel OneTouch Idol Ultra

Alcatel OneTouch Idol Ultra

18 Jun, 2013, 02:14 AM

LG X Boom CM9730 Video Review

LG X Boom CM9730 Video Review

21 May, 2013, 05:42 AM

3.2

MORE VIDEOS

Best desktop speakers for audiophiles on a budget

Best desktop speakers for audiophiles on a budget

Here are two of the best active desktop stereo speakers you can buy...

By Nachiket Mhatre

Buying Guide - PC Speakers

Buying Guide - PC Speakers

Your first step would be to figure out whether you want surround sound or...

By Siddharth Basrur

Surround Sound - Setup Basics

Surround Sound - Setup Basics

How to set up your surround sound system without making too much of a mess.

By Siddharth Basrur

MORE FEATURES

PlayStation 4 up for pre-order in India

Shishir Mukherjee

Thu Jun 20, 13:48:06

Catch 22: Microsoft Xbox One or Sony PlayStation 4?

Shishir Mukherjee

Thu Jun 20, 13:44:50

MORE DISCUSSIONS